Paying for Fake News When the Truth Will Set You Free

Intentional ignorance and misinformation is well-funded.


Because it works. If I can pay a few highly influential voices to craft a compelling narrative to scare you, then you are much easier to control.

Stanford University recently released a report highlighting how difficult it is in this information age to discern what is or is not a credible source.

There are people convinced that Dearborn, a city on the east side of Michigan with high Muslim and Arab populations, recently implemented Sharia law in all official aspects. Fearful community members are gossiping in salons and bars about the horrifying implications of this “fact.” National Report, whose tagline is “America’s #1 Independent News Source,” posted an article reporting on this huge story.

National Report, however, is a satire news site. It’s not obvious at first glance, but there is a disclaimer if you look for one. Of course, why would you look further if this “news” upholds your preconceived ideas? Nevermind the fact that this “story” was posted three years ago and has since been removed. Nevermind that Snopes has clearly identified it as fake news. And just in case you were determined to believe it as fact anyway, Truth and Action has curated another version of the same “story” to prove its legitimacy.

Trump’s campaign has been intentionally, not incidentally, Islamophobic. Built on a campaign of fear-mongering and misinformation, Islamophobia was a winning message in this campaign cycle. The fear experienced by Muslims in America is real, and for good reasonIslamophobia is likely to become national policy.

But the truth is that Islamophobia is a fake fear, albeit one that is well-funded by those who wish to be seen as powerful saviors from the evil other.

Religious extremism is dangerous, but is not limited to Islam.

I identify as a Christian pluralist. What this means to me is that I personally find a path to truth and redemption through Jesus as Christ, but I respect others’ distinct religious identities and accept that their paths to truth and redemption are no less legitimate. From this lens, I not only look for the salvific good in other religions, but also the distorted evils of my own religion. The KKK and Westboro Baptist Church are distortions of Christianity that stand out as extreme. It’s harder to see gentler, more palatable extremism that insidiously pervades our American culture, because it’s carefully hidden behind “good Christian values.”

Christians in America experience religious privilege grounded in subtle Christian triumphalism. In gentler terms it might sound like inclusivism, but it’s ultimately grounded in a belief that Christianity is right and possesses the truth, therefore anyone not Christian is wrong and does not possess the truth.

Muslims are assertively rejecting extremism. And American evangelical Christians voted religious extremism into the most powerful office in the world.

The echo chamber of misinformation is a tool of violence utilized by wealthy extremists paying for fake news.

But Jesus said the truth will set you free. Seeking out true stories is possible.

If those who are committed to truth seek out these hidden stories, the “us vs. them” binary narrative of fear may be dispelled. Rather than glom onto whatever fake news upholds their ideas, truth-seekers complicate the narrative and see the shared experience of humanity.

As a Christian pluralist, I commit to seeking truth where it may be found. As a public theologian, I commit to analyzing my news sources and refusing to perpetuate fake news. Will you join with me and other members of my seminary’s public theology course in pledging to do the same? Click here for the link to sign and share.

Freedom is possible in truth. Insist on it.


One thought on “Paying for Fake News When the Truth Will Set You Free

  1. I used both the videos you selected! The one from Amazon led me down an entirely different train of thought about how “crass” marketing, so decried by the left, can actually be a tool of the Spirit. Duh, Kathy! Just something I hadn’t considered before. Thank you for putting the link to “the pledge” on your page. My next blogpost will do the same.
    I think we, the public, get what we ask for. If we are getting fake news, it is because there is a market for that. If only a handful of us insist on fact-checking and truthful reporting, maybe it will spread. Because even the people I know who cherry-pick their news according to their worldview, are getting very tired of all the ersatz crap out there.

    Thank you for yet another wonderfully powerful post!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s